· GregglesTV · Home & Gear

iFixit Tore Down Apple HomeView, and It's One of the Hardest Apple Devices to Repair in Years

iFixit's Apple HomeView teardown found glue nearly everywhere, a display that fought back, a speaker that snapped and a logic board bonded to the chassis. It also explains why the wall-mounted HomeView has smaller speakers. Here's what they found.

iFixit Tore Down Apple HomeView, and It's One of the Hardest Apple Devices to Repair in Years
Image: Apple

Quick summary: iFixit published its teardown of Apple’s new HomeView smart display today, and it did not go well. After a run of Apple products that were easier to open up, iFixit says HomeView fought them almost the whole way, with glue and adhesive on the display, speakers, antennas and logic board. If you just bought a HomeView, it still works great, but don’t plan on fixing one yourself.

What iFixit found

Here are the highlights, from 9to5Mac and The Verge, which both covered the teardown:

  • The display glue was brutal. iFixit told The Verge the glue holding the screen in place “held on harder than on any Apple product we’ve opened recently.”
  • Things broke along the way. By the time they got it apart, iFixit says its techs had “ripped a connector, snapped a speaker in two, and put more force on the poor logic board than any of us were comfortable with.” 9to5Mac notes that happened even after soaking the speaker adhesive in isopropyl alcohol.
  • The logic board is bonded to the chassis. Apple uses the whole aluminum body as a heat sink, which The Verge calls clever, but the thermal bond to the board made separating them a “remarkably risky operation,” according to iFixit.
  • The screen and base are hard to separate. On the tabletop model, the cables run through the hinge, so splitting the display from the base takes special tools or a lot of potentially destructive disassembly, per 9to5Mac.
  • Some good news in the base. The USB-C port is modular and fairly easy to get to, as are the passive radiators and the board for the lower section. But a very short woofer cable had iFixit wondering how anyone would reconnect it.

iFixit doesn’t have an official repair score for this kind of device, but 9to5Mac says iFixit’s Shahram Mokhtari jokingly gave it a “BEEP this thing” out of 10.

Why the wall-mounted HomeView sounds different

This is the part I found most useful for buyers. iFixit tore down both versions, and 9to5Mac reports the wall-mounted model has a slightly wider logic board to fit capacitors that live in the base on the tabletop version. That leaves room for smaller speakers, which helps explain the audio difference Apple already acknowledged at launch.

Both versions cost $299, according to Apple, but the wall version needs a separately sold Schneider Home mount, starting at $59.95 for the Power Mount USB-C Wall Connector. The Verge says iFixit came away feeling wall-mount buyers get less audio performance while spending more.

My take

I wouldn’t let this stop you from buying a HomeView, but it should change how you protect it. Since repairs look tough, put it somewhere it won’t get knocked off a counter or splashed. And if sound matters to you, the teardown backs up what I’d tell anyone: go with the tabletop model unless you really need it on the wall. If you’d rather have a cheaper smart display, the Echo Show 8 is still a solid pick, and Apple TV 4K can also act as your Apple Home hub.

Sources: 9to5Mac, The Verge, MacRumors, Apple Newsroom.


Subscribe to GregglesTV for daily tech news, reviews and walkthroughs.

See today’s GregglesTV Best Tech Deals or browse all deals posts.

Comments

Comments are moderated. Hate, slurs, spam and scam posts are blocked. Don’t include personal info you wouldn’t want public. See the privacy policy.

Loading comments…

Price-drop alert

Get an alert

One email if the price drops. No spam, unsubscribe anytime. See the privacy policy.